Scripture Matthew 19:27-30
Peter said [to Jesus], “Look, we have left everything and followed you. What then will we have?” Jesus said to them, “Truly I tell you all who have followed me, at the renewal of all things, when the Son of Woman is seated at the throne of his glory, you all shall also sit on twelve thrones, judging the twelve tribes of Israel. And whoever has left houses or sisters or brothers or mother or father or children or fields, for the sake of my name, will receive a hundredfold, and will inherit eternal life. But many who are first will be last, and the last will be first.”
Translation: Rev. Wilda Gafney, A Women’s Lectionary for the Whole Church, Year A.
Sermon
This morning’s passage is difficult. Where is the good news? We might even sum up Jesus’s response as an empty, unprovable promise, “pie in the sky in the by and by!” Or is there a deeper good news beyond wild sentences such as, “You shall be seated on twelve thrones, judging the twelve tribes of Israel”? I believe there is. I believe this passage goes right to the heart of what it means to be a disciple, a follower of Jesus.
This conversation between Jesus and Peter takes place immediately after Jesus’s encounter with the unnamed “rich young man,” who was unable to follow, and yet, whom Jesus loved. After all, the young man has done everything right so far. He hungers for eternal life, the kind of life in Christ that begins in this world and continues into the next. He has honored the commandments. But Jesus’ final demand on him is one he can cannot fulfil: He cannot bear parting with his wealth as a prerequisite for following Jesus. After the young man walks away sad, Jesus speaks to his disciples on the near-impossibility of reconciling love for God with love of money.
The disciples are on the road to Jerusalem with Jesus. By now, they have heard his prophecy of his own death two times. Somehow, they still hold out hope that the “renewal of all things” will have to do with Jesus being the recognized, triumphant king of Judah, somehow toppling the forces of both Herod and the Roman Empire. They envision Jesus being honored, and gaining the privileges of royalty, and they imagine that wealth trickling down to them. But now, the issue of money has come up. And Jesus’s warning about wealth stirs Peter to speak frankly. “Look, he says, “we have left everything and followed you.” And then he asks a blunt question: “What then will we have?”
Someone asked during Bible Study this week, “Were the disciples married?” And the answer for Peter is a solid “Yes,” because we know that Jesus cured Peter’s mother-in-law of a fever in chapter 8. But yes, it is likely that most of the disciples were married, except maybe for the youngest. They left behind wives and children, parents and siblings. Sometimes they left behind the family business, as for the four fishermen. In other cases, in this feudal society, it is likely they left behind parcels of land they farmed on behalf of a wealthy owner, who allowed them to keep a small amount of their earnings for themselves. They left behind communities, including faith communities, their local synagogues. Following Jesus has already come at a cost. For nearly all the twelve, that cost will eventually include their lives.
And now, for the first time since he called them away from their boats and their nets, their fields and their family, the quiet question has been said aloud: “How does this benefit me?”
I wonder whether this life of transience—walking from village to village, staying with the strangers who welcome them, not seeing their loved ones for weeks or months on end, or perhaps never again—I wonder whether it is wearing them down. Could they be burnt out? They wouldn’t be the last followers of Jesus to experience fatigue, and with Jesus’s words about his death, anticipatory grief and trauma. Or, maybe it’s just Peter, and the other disciples are shocked at his question. OR. Maybe, this is Peter the Wise, making sure the other disciples understand the cost of their discipleship.
Dietrich Bonhoeffer offers some insight to this passage as regards faith and obedience. He notes that the disciples all have an instinctive, immediate response to Jesus’ call to follow him. He compares that response to other people we meet in the gospels, including the rich young man. According to his analysis, the disciples jumping up and leaving every single person and thing in their lives behind, is an act of obedience. And because they are obedient, they have faith in the one they’re following. At the same time, it is because of their faith, or faithfulness, that they can be obedient. For Bonhoeffer, you cannot have faith without obedience, and you cannot have obedience without faith. The two are inextricably intertwined.[i]
The rich young man, on the other hand, seems genuinely to want to follow Jesus. But is that really the case? Do you remember how, when Jesus tells him to “Keep the commandments,” he asks, “Which ones?” What a funny thing to say. It’s as if he’s looking for a way out, even before Jesus asks him to sell all he has and give it to the poor.
Let’s talk about that word, obedience. The context of Jesus’s mission and ministry was one in which most people belonged to someone else. We see the word “servant” a lot in the New Testament, but that’s a weak translation of a word that really means “slave.” People who farm the lands of others, even fishermen, most of whom had to lease their boats and hand a substantial portion of their income to the owner of the boats—all these were in some way enslaved to someone higher on the food chain. Which means, the concept of obedience in everyday life was expected and accepted.
We, on the other hand, live in a society that values human agency above almost everything else—we Americans have been promised life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, all of which are results of our acting according to our free will. Except for some unusual settings, most of us don’t sit down with the folks in HR to talk about whether we’re being obedient to our bosses. We have other language for that—we are, or are not, team players. We understand the work assigned to us and do it to our best ability. Obedience is rarely cited as a “value” in, let’s say, a Manual of Operations.
But Bonhoeffer ties obedience to faithfulness; they are inseparable. You or I might rename it. Let’s call it, for example, wholeheartedness. Can we give our lives to God, to Jesus, wholeheartedly? Can we believe that his words and his ways are truly the way, the truth, and the life for us? If we trust Bonhoeffer’s theorem, we might say that giving our lives to Jesus wholeheartedly is the exact way to be able to trust in God, to trust in Jesus. And vice versa. Trusting in God is the way we are able to give ourselves wholeheartedly.
Our passage from Paul’s letter to the Philippians seems to support this idea. Paul is in prison in Rome which means, he’s near the end of his life. He will be executed for the same crime Jesus supposedly committed: treason. And yet, Paul is sharing his pure joy with the Philippians, because the centurions and guards all know that he is imprisoned for Christ, and that has led to the good news spreading, not only throughout the Praetorium, but also throughout the city. Paul is in prison, and yet this letter is known as the “Epistle of Joy” because Paul’s heart is so light throughout, and he cannot stop saying how deep and wide his joy is. He cannot stop rejoicing. Bonhoeffer would say that Paul’s obedience has given him faith, and his faith has made him obedient. I would say that Paul’s wholeheartedness has led him to utter trust and faithfulness in Jesus, and his faithfulness has made him wholehearted.
I have no doubt that the disciples have faith and trust Jesus, though they don’t always understand him. Is Peter’s question a moment of doubt, or is it something else—a search for greater understanding, maybe? Jesus’s answer starts, “At the renewal of all things,” which is another way of saying, “At the end times,” “At the moment when God reigns throughout this world and makes everything right,” or “In eternal life.” But eternal life is something we have the moment we are wholeheartedly committed to Jesus. Eternal life begins here, on this plane. Jesus says that those who have “left houses or sisters or brothers or mother or father or children or fields, for the sake of [his] name, will receive a hundredfold, and will inherit eternal life.” And that promise is a promise for this life as well. Discipleship is costly. Of course it is. Not in the sense of a transaction—this for that—but in the sense that it can be hard. At times we may feel unsure, or alienated from people who don’t understand. But discipleship also infuses us with a deep joy that is unconquerable. We begin to understand what Jesus means when he says,
“Come to me, all you who are weary and are carrying heavy burdens, and I will give you rest. Take my yoke upon you, and learn from me, for I am gentle and humble in heart, and you will find rest for your souls. For my yoke is easy, and my burden is light.” ~Matthew 11:28-30
Peter says [to Jesus], “Look, we have left everything and followed you. What then will we have?” And if we listen deeply, we can hear Jesus reply, you will have joy upon joy, and grace upon grace. You will have hard days, and painful nights, and at the same time, give thanks to God in heaven for the joy that following me has blessed you with. You will know what the realm of God is, not only in the life that comes after, but in this life. You will live it. You will revel in it, for my yoke is easy, and my burden is light. And you will find rest for your souls.
Thanks be to God. Amen.
[i] Dietrich Bonhoeffer, The Cost of Discipleship, Chapter 2.
